Before Story Became Story
Patty Wolfe and the Family Behind a Wyoming Community
Today, Story, Wyoming, is known for its towering pines, mountain streams, quiet roads and its setting against the Bighorn Mountains. But behind the beginnings of this small mountain community are real people whose lives were considerably harder and more complicated than the peaceful surroundings might suggest.
One of those people was Patty Wilson Henderson Wolfe.
Born in 1860, Patty, whose first name is also recorded as Pattie, lived through an extraordinary period of western history. Her diary from 1916 offers something particularly valuable to the people of Story today: a personal glimpse into the family connected to one of the central figures in the community's beginnings.
Patty's husband was Marshall Lee Wolfe, born in 1843. The couple married on May 22, 1882. By the time Patty was keeping this portion of her diary in 1916, they were separated, but Marshall remained part of her life.
And Marshall Wolfe was no incidental figure in Story's past.
He helped put Story on the map.
The Wolfe Connection to Story
According to historical accounts published by Sheridan Media, Marshall Lee Wolfe came to Wyoming in 1895 and entered the cattle business. Before coming west, he had served as a Missouri mine inspector under Governor John B. Marmaduke. By the opening years of the 20th century, Wolfe had become one of the men actively promoting the little settlement beneath the Bighorn Mountains.
Historical accounts differ somewhat in their descriptions of the precise sequence of Story's founding, but they agree on Wolfe's central role. Sheridan Media reports that Wolfe was responsible for platting the early town and that he originally wanted the community to bear his own name. “Wolf,” however, was already in use elsewhere in Wyoming. The new community instead became Story, honoring Charles B. Story, who was instrumental in establishing its post office.
Another historical account notes that the first registered letter associated with the Story Post Office dates to January 29, 1902, although sources differ over the exact date the post office began operating. Whatever the precise date, the historical record credits Marshall Lee Wolfe with helping put Story on the map during this period.
That makes Patty's diary more than one Wyoming woman's record of daily life.
It is a surviving personal record from the family of one of Story's early promoters.
Marshall Wolfe Was Selling a Vision of Story
Marshall apparently saw something special in the Piney country.
In 1905, the Cheyenne Daily Leader, drawing from a Denver newspaper account, described Wolfe attending a stock growers' convention and bringing samples of Wyoming grain, coal and oil with him to Denver. His purpose was essentially promotional: he wanted people outside Wyoming to recognize the potential of the country surrounding Story.
The newspaper described Wolfe as regarding Story as almost an earthly Eden.
The description that followed would sound familiar to anyone who lives in Story today: mountain valleys, the Piney River and its tributaries, snow-covered Bighorn peaks, abundant water and spectacular scenery.
More than 120 years later, those natural surroundings remain at the heart of Story's identity.
Wolfe was promoting them when the community was barely beginning.
By 1908, newspapers were already envisioning the Piney district as a destination for summer homes and visitors seeking mountain scenery, fishing, hunting and a cooler climate. Story was being described as a community nestled among the pines with the potential to become a well-known western resort.
Behind those optimistic newspaper descriptions, however, was the everyday life experienced by families like the Wolfes.
Patty's diary helps us see that side of the story.
Patty's Wyoming Was Built Around Work
Patty did not write her diary for publication.
Her entries are brief and practical.
On January 1, 1916, she wrote:
“Not so cold, washing babe’s things. Iron and getting ready to go to Sheridan.”
The following day involved a trip toward Sheridan. Family members were dropped off along the way, and Patty eventually reached Sheridan late in the afternoon.
That was the rhythm of her life.
Wash.
Iron.
Bake.
Churn.
Write letters.
Travel to Sheridan or Buffalo.
Care for children.
Prepare meals.
Watch the weather.
Wait for the mail.
The diary reminds us that the history of places like Story wasn't created only by the men whose names appeared in newspapers and land records. Communities survived because of the mostly unrecorded labor taking place inside homes, barns, gardens and kitchens.
Patty recorded that world.
When Winter Controlled Everything
Weather dominates Patty's diary.
That makes sense to anyone familiar with life at the foot of the Bighorns.
Snow could determine whether someone went to town. Wind could change plans within hours. Washing clothes depended partly upon whether they could be hung outside.
Travel that today might require a short drive could become a significant undertaking.
January 1916 became brutally cold.
On January 27, Patty recorded a report of 34 degrees below zero early in the morning.
The next morning was 24 below.
Yet the work continued.
She washed and ironed. Bread was baked. Letters were written. Children were cared for.
People traveled when necessary.
Her entries rarely complain.
The weather is simply recorded as another reality that had to be dealt with.
Life and Death Close Together
Patty's diary also shows how closely joy, work and grief existed beside one another.
Early in January, a baby in the extended family became seriously ill. Patty traveled to help.
For several days she documented the child's condition.
There were moments when the baby appeared to improve. Then came January 18.
Patty wrote:
“The little babe sinking.”
Later that day came the devastatingly simple entry:
“10 minutes of 1, babe dies.”
The following morning family members took the child's body toward Clearmont to bury him beside another child.
Then Patty returned to recording ordinary life.
Clothes.
Chickens.
Meals.
Letters.
Illness and death appear repeatedly throughout the diary. Neighbors died. Family members became sick. People traveled to help one another.
There was grief, but there was also work that could not wait.
The Community Behind the Community
Another feature of Patty's diary is how frequently people appear at the house.
Someone came for dinner.
Someone stayed overnight.
A neighbor stopped in.
A man working nearby ate with the family.
Family members arrived and departed.
Someone needed help.
Someone brought news.
The impression is not one of isolation but of interdependence.
That is important when thinking about the origins of Story.
A town is more than a plat on a map or the establishment of a post office. Long before there are established businesses, paved roads and community institutions, there are relationships.
People depend upon one another.
Patty's diary captures that informal network.
Letters Connected Patty's World
If work forms one rhythm of Patty's diary, letters form another.
She was constantly sending and receiving correspondence.
Annie.
Emma.
Frank.
Bird.
Mrs. Harris.
Mr. Cotton.
Others appear repeatedly.
News traveled through those letters, birthdays, sickness, deaths, family matters and ordinary conversation.
A card or letter might represent the only connection between family members separated by hundreds of miles.
That becomes especially important later in Patty's story because her family stretched far beyond the Piney country.
From Wyoming to Canada
In May 1916, 56-year-old Patty embarked on a substantial journey to visit Frank in Canada.
She traveled through Sheridan and Billings, Montana, continued to Shelby, crossed the
Canadian border and took the train toward Calgary.
Think about the span of history contained within that one woman's lifetime.
Patty had been born in 1860, before the Civil War began.
Now she was traveling alone by railroad across an international border.
Yet when she arrived, her diary immediately returned to the things that mattered in daily life.
Rain.
Meals.
Laundry.
Potatoes.
Visitors.
Family.
She helped Frank cut and plant potatoes. She washed clothes when the weather allowed. She helped with work around the ranch.
In June she recorded cattle being gathered and calves vaccinated.
Then came another wonderfully characteristic Patty entry:
“We iron, bake bread and churn.”
Hundreds of miles from Wyoming, her daily rhythm continued.
Coming Back to Wyoming
Patty's return trip in June was complicated.
She traveled from the ranch to Bassano, then toward Medicine Hat and the international border. There were train changes, problems involving baggage, long waits and connections through Montana before she eventually reached Sheridan.
Finally, she arrived back at Bird's.
Her conclusion was only two words:
“all well.”
Those words tell us something about Patty.
After weeks away and hundreds of miles of travel, what mattered was that she had arrived and her family was well.
Then a Familiar Name Appears
Near the very end of this first section of Patty's diary, an entry suddenly connects her personal record directly back to the early history of Story.
On June 26, Patty washed clothes, baked bread and wrote letters while a man came to paint the house.
Then, on June 27, she wrote:
“A warm day. Churn and iron. Mr. Wolfe comes this eve.”
The “Mr. Wolfe” was her husband, Marshall Lee Wolfe.
The man who appears so casually in Patty's diary is the same man historical accounts associate with the beginnings and promotion of Story.
Two days later, Patty wrote simply:
“A good breeze. This morning Mr. left.”
The surviving diary includes an editorial note explaining that Patty and Marshall were separated by this time and that references to “Mr. Wolfe” refer to her husband.
That small entry creates a remarkable connection.
In histories of Story, Marshall Wolfe appears as a cattleman, town promoter and early developer, the man who wanted to name the settlement Wolfe and who traveled with samples of local resources to promote the Piney country.
In Patty's diary, he is simply:
“Mr. Wolfe.”
History becomes personal.
The Woman Beside Story's Early History
Marshall Lee Wolfe lived until 1937, long enough to see the little community he helped promote become an established place beneath the Bighorns.
Patty did not live as long. She died in 1926.
But her diary leaves Story something that newspaper accounts and official records cannot.
It gives us the texture of the world from which the community emerged.
The Story of the early 1900s wasn't simply the beautiful mountain destination promoted to outsiders. It was a place where winter could reach more than 30 degrees below zero. Roads became impassable. Families depended upon gardens, livestock and one another. Women washed clothes by hand, churned butter and baked bread while caring for children. Letters carried family news across states and international borders.
People buried children and neighbors.
They welcomed strangers for supper.
They traveled enormous distances.
And the next morning, they got up and worked again.
That was the world Patty Wilson Henderson Wolfe recorded.
Today we drive through Story and see homes tucked beneath the pines, the creeks flowing out of the mountains and the Bighorns rising immediately to the west. Much of the beauty Marshall Wolfe was promoting more than a century ago remains recognizable.
But Patty's diary reminds us that Story was not built from scenery alone.
It was built from people.
People who worked, traveled, planted, cooked, grieved, helped their neighbors and built lives in a demanding place.
Marshall Wolfe helped put Story on the map.
Patty Wolfe helps us understand something equally important:
what life behind that map actually looked like.
This is Part One of our look at the diary of Patty Wilson Henderson Wolfe and her family's connection to the early history of Story, Wyoming.
Thank you to the Story Woman’s Club for giving me access to the Story Museum and its historical resources, which helped make this article possible.
Stay connected to the people, events, and stories that make Story and the surrounding communities special by liking and following the StoryWyoming.org Facebook page.
